Skip to content
Simple Collective UK

Referendum Defeat Makes Italy's Giorgia Meloni Looking More Weakened.

PM Meloni addressing the vote outcome
Giorgia Meloni said the ballot was a squandered moment to modernise Italy.

Italy's Head of Government Giorgia Meloni has suffered a loss in a key constitutional referendum, which effectively turned into a general assessment on her government.

The official result gave roughly 54% to the "Against" campaign and 46% to the "For" vote that the Premier had vigorously supported.

"Italians have voted clearly," she commented in a social media post, released even before all ballots were tallied. "I will abide by their verdict, but I am sorry for a missed opportunity to reform the nation."

This represents the first major reversal for PM Meloni and her right-wing coalition, which has overseen a unusual period of political stability for Italy. Opposition parties are hailing the decision as a strong indicator that the electorate are looking for an alternative, with a general election scheduled next year.

The Vote Count

When the 48-hour vote wrapped up on Monday afternoon, initial surveys indicated the "Against" campaign leading by a narrow margin. Yet, that advantage widened to a substantial one as the ballot counting progressed.

In spite of the technical proposition on the referendum form, participation was close to 60%. A strong participation had been widely expected to favor the administration, but it was not enough to alter the overall result.

The Rejected Reform

The judicial overhaul that the electorate rejected would have inscribed a firm division between the judiciary and public prosecutors into the constitution. It also proposed separate institutions to govern them and a new disciplinary court.

The administration argued the change was vital to enhancing the autonomy of the courts. The opposition responded that it would disrupt a delicate system of checks and balances established following the fall of the fascist regime, and increase partisan control over the legal system.

A significant number of Italians found it difficult to comprehend the complexities – maybe a communication failure by her government – and the vote quickly morphed into a national judgment on her extended three and a half years in government.

Gatherings by opposition voters
Opposition voters turned out to celebrate their victory.

Challenging Circumstances

The defeat came at a trying time. Meloni is a close ally of ex-US President Donald Trump, whose approval has reportedly waned in Italy, along with approval of his policies on the Middle East conflict.

Furthermore, with Italy's economic growth sluggish, many people are anxious about the war's consequences on fuel prices and overall inflation.

Fallout

Meloni had categorically rejected quitting, whatever the outcome. This is unlike the approach of former PM Matteo Renzi in 2016, who called his own constitutional referendum as prime minister and resigned after suffering a loss.

"This referendum is not about me, but about justice," she had stated before the poll.

When the outcome became clear, Renzi advised that her administration had now forfeited its "popular appeal" and needed to listen more closely to public sentiment. "Losing and brushing it off just is not possible," he reportedly told Italian radio.

A victory would have almost certainly encouraged her to pursue other political ambitions, including a further reform to introduce direct elections for the head of government.

On the contrary, rival Democratic Party leader Elly Schlein proclaimed that Meloni's defeat demonstrated "that there exists an different choice to this government" in the run-up to next year's parliamentary polls.

This setback has undoubtedly rubbed some of the luster off the coalition and Meloni herself, hitherto the the strong woman of Italian politics, has been made looking increasingly exposed.

CE
Written by

Christina Esparza

A minimalist lifestyle advocate and writer exploring simplicity and sustainability.

Simple Collective UK

Type to search articles.